The movie mythologizes Patton, perhaps more than some will be able to stand, but it also provides insight into the deeply intimidating prospect of a man with a definitively singular purpose. Patton’s approach to war could be described as thrilling by some. Others would call it sad, or perhaps even terrifying. George C. Scott’s performance suggest all three, creating a vital portrait of one of the most noted figures in American military history.
Watch if: You want to see a fascinating depiction of a fascinating, terribly flawed man. Avoid if: You don’t like war movies with controversial figures presented in heroic terms.
The anti-war ideas often associated with M*A*S*H belong more to the considerably-more-famous TV show that came out of film.
Robert Altman’s 1970 ensemble comedy has a lot to say about the futility of the concept, but the real teeth of the movie are used on the various components of the industrial-military complex. The paperwork attitudes of those who send individuals like Hawkeye, Duke, Trapper John, and Hot Lips into hellish combat zones in the first place.
The movie is so freewheeling in its pace and overall energy, it’s easy to lose track of what it’s all supposed to be about. If M*A*S*H isn’t about anything meaningful, then at least it rests well on deranged men making the most of a bad situation.
Watch if: You like comedies that can be appreciated in a number of different ways. Avoid if: There’s a Black character named Spearchucker (played by the legendary Fred Williamson). You should probably just decide now if you’re going to be okay with that.
8. The Deer Hunter (1978)
Christopher Walken, who figures prominently in the movie’s most iconic scene, won an Academy Award for his portrayal of a Pennsylvania steel worker who is changed forever by his experiences during the Vietnam War.
The politics of The Deer Hunter, which features amazing performances from Meryl Streep (nominated for her first Oscar, and then we never heard from her again), Robert De Niro, and John Cazale (his final performance), have been heavily debated for years. It doesn’t help the debate that no one can even agree on who wrote what in the film’s massive screenplay.
The Deer Hunter showcases bleak futures under the specter of not only one war or another, but also the rituals of our surroundings.
Watch if: You like movies packed with good performances. Avoid if: You have a romantic impression of the game Russian Roulette.
9. The Tin Drum (1979)
This might be the controversial choice on this list. I’ll argue the merits of this deranged, endlessly fascinating war drama until the end of the time, or the start of World War III.
The Tin Drum is a German film based on a novel by Günter Grass. It was directed and cowritten by Volker Schlöndorff. Although Schlöndorff is still directing good stuff to this day, The Tin Drum is probably his masterpiece. There is something about the tone of this movie, in which a young boy’s obsession with a tin drum carries him through World War II and beyond, in which everything seems to be building to a conclusion that will scorch the earth.
There is something absolutely insane and desperate about this film, which is also one of the weirdest World War II movies ever made.
Watch if: You like surrealism and absurdity more than just about anything. Avoid if: You like surrealism and absurdity, but only when those things make sense.
I think one of the best things about Francis Ford Coppola’s Vietnam epic Apocalypse Now is the fact that it is appreciated by so many different groups of people.
Some appreciate the connections shared between the novella Heart of Darkness and this story of an army captain (Martin Sheen, in one of his best) tasked with an increasingly unstable mission to take out a U.S. colonel who has gone insane. Others claim this movie makes one appreciate the various facets of war like no other. Others still focus on how this rambling, lengthy (2 ½ hours) story manages to maintain such a blistering focus on dissecting everything possible about the Vietnam War.
Personally? I’m always fascinated by the choices people make in relentlessly perilous situations.
Watch if: You want to see a fever dream that doesn’t let up for even a second. Avoid if: Excess in filmmaking bothers you.
11. Saving Private Ryan (1998)
Actually, I was wrong. As far as I’m concerned, this might be the most controversial choice for best war movies. Mostly for the fact that after the first 27 minutes of Saving Private Ryan, it is highly debatable that Steven Spielberg’s World War II marathon is worth watching after that. At 169 minutes, I’ll leave it up to you to decide.
Performances from Tom Hanks, Tom Sizemore, and Matt Damon range from good-to-great, but everything pales in comparison to those first 27 minutes. Those are the moments in which Spielberg recreates the landing at Omaha Beach, part of the Normandy Invasion, with such overwhelming attention to detail, you will probably forget to blink.
That might be a good way to describe Spielberg as a director in general. When he’s good, it’s on a level that makes you willing to sit through 142 minutes of hit-or-miss Oscar bait dramatics.
Then again, I know a lot of people who like the entire film. You might be one of them.
Watch if: You want to see the most intense depiction of D-Day at Normandy that anyone will ever commit to a fictional film. Avoid if: You have a low threshold for Steven Spielberg movies.
12. The Hurt Locker (2008)
Kathryn Bigelow deservedly won an Oscar for directing what I still believe to be one of the best movies about the Iraq War made to date.
Anchored by Jeremy Renner as the leader of an Explosive Ordnance Disposal unit, The Hurt Locker swirls the politics of the greedy and stupid, crazed violence, and palpable tension and uncertainty around Renner’s character. All the while, exploring the machinations of what creates a person who can seemingly only function under the unforgiving circumstances of a potentially endless conflict.
The Hurt Locker has all of that, while simultaneously being one of the best action movies of the 2000s.
Watch if: You want to see a pretty engaging action movie. Avoid if: You need comprehensive accuracy in your Iraq War movies.
It helps a little to know the basics of the Lebanon War, which occurred in 1982. However, even if you don’t go that far, Lebanon is as riveting as it is unique.
Set inside a tank during the conflict, you can expect that claustrophobia to set in early, building as the movie roars into increasingly dangerous situations. Throughout such an atmosphere, it is inevitable that we learn a great deal about the four Israeli soldiers inside the tank.
While Lebanon is absolutely steeped in the politics of its time, place, and peoples, it is still one of the most stirring anti-war movies made in this decade. It challenges perceptions at a near-constant pace, which is wonderfully exhausting when combined with the nervous energy of the movie itself.
Watch if: You want to see one of the most unique war movies made in recent years. Avoid if: I suppose it depends on your politics.
14. Beasts of No Nation (2015)
Set in a West African country (we never learn which) during a civil war, Beasts of No Nation is not the first in a line of movies about child soldiers.
At the same time, few films defy your expectations of such a story as deftly and profoundly as writer/director Cary Joji Fukunaga does here. It doesn’t hurt that Beasts of No Nation also spotlights amazing performances from Abraham Attah and Idris Elba.
Beasts of No Nation presents its story in a visually provocative way, but there is nothing glorious about the way this film is laid out.
Watch if: You want to see a strong case for Netflix’s legitimacy with their original releases. Avoid if: You have a weak tolerance for children put through absolute hell.
15. Dunkirk (2017)
Say what you will about Christopher Nolan. As pretentious as his films can sometimes be/seem, he is also one of the leading innovators of the modern-day epic.
Dunkirk isn’t the first movie about the extraordinary evacuation of some 30,000 Allied soldiers during the Second World War, but it is a masterwork of timing, performance, atmosphere, and attention to detail.
It doesn’t glorify war, as far too many war movies have done. It simply compels one to remember that heroism nonetheless still occurs within situations that ideally wouldn’t happen at all.
Watch if: You want to see a truly awe-inspiring historical reenactment. Avoid if: You’re over the whole Christopher Nolan thing.
Despite war movies not being among my favorite types of films, it wasn’t hard to come up with a long list of potential contenders. Believe me, for one reason or another, there are many films beyond the 15 best war movies highlighted here, or the 5 runners up presented below, in no particular order:
– Black Hawk Down (2001) – The Battle of Algiers (1966) – Platoon (1986) – Come and See (1985) – Richard III (1995)